Introduction
People who have an asthma attack have real trouble taking a breath. Many people with stuffy noses from hay fever or colds say “I can’t breathe,” but they retain the option of breathing through the mouth. For asthmatics, the bronchial tubes in their lungs become swollen and clogged. Breathing can become frighteningly difficult.
Asthma involves two conditions: contraction of the small
muscles surrounding the bronchial tubes and inflammation of the lining of those
tubes. Traditionally, treatment primarily addressed the first aspect of asthma;
recently, however, it has become clear that tissue swelling is the underlying
cause.
The conventional treatment of asthma is highly effective for most people.
Treatments include both short- and long-acting bronchodilators, which relax the
bronchial muscles, and anti-inflammatory medication, which helps relieve the
swelling of tissue. Bronchodilators alone may be sufficient treatment for mild
asthma or asthma that occurs only with exercise. Anti-inflammatory steroids in the
cortisone family taken by inhalation are the mainstay of treatment for moderate to
severe asthma. Although these are much safer than oral steroids, they may still
increase risk of osteoporosis and other problems when they are taken in high
doses or for a long time. Other drugs used to reduce inflammation include
montelukast (Singulair), nedocromil (Tilade) and cromolyn (Intal). (Intal is
derived from a Mediterranean herb named khella.) The newest drug treatment for
asthma, omalizumab (Xolair), appears to be safe and effective, but it is extremely
expensive, and for this reason, it is seldom used.
Principal Proposed Natural Treatments
None of these treatments has been shown to be effective for severe asthma. One should not stop standard asthma medication except on the advice of a physician.
The herb Tylophora indica (also called T. asthmatica) appears to offer some promise as a treatment for asthma. It has a long history of use in the traditional Ayurvedic medicine of India. However, all of the studies on this herb were performed in India long ago and failed to reach modern standards of design and reporting.
In a double-blind, placebo-controlled study of 195 persons with asthma, the participants who were given 40 milligrams (mg) of a tylophora alcohol extract daily for six days showed significant improvement compared with placebo. Similar results were seen in two double-blind, placebo-controlled studies involving more than two hundred persons with asthma. However, the design of these studies was a bit convoluted, and various pieces of information are missing from the reports, causing some difficulty in evaluating the validity of these trials.
Another double-blind study that enrolled 135 persons and followed a more straightforward design found no benefit from tylophora. Although tylophora is promising, larger and better studies are necessary to discover whether tylophora is truly effective.
Boswellia. The herb boswellia has shown promise as a treatment
for rheumatoid
arthritis. It is thought to work by inhibiting inflammation.
Because asthma involves inflammation and can be treated by some of the same drugs
that treat rheumatoid arthritis, boswellia has been tried for this purpose
too.
One six-week, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of eighty persons with relatively mild asthma found that treatment with boswellia at a dose of 300 mg three times daily reduced the frequency of asthma attacks and improved objective measurements of breathing capacity. However, further research needs to be performed to follow up this pilot study before boswellia can be described as a proven treatment for asthma.
Coleus forskohlii. Another herb sometimes recommended for asthma also comes from India, Coleus forskohlii. While there is some preliminary evidence that it might have value, this evidence is far too weak to be relied on. Furthermore, as sold, the herb is more like a drug than an herb. Natural C. forskohlii contains small amounts of a potent chemical called forskolin. Manufacturers deliberately modify the herb to dramatically increase its forskolin content; therefore, when using such products, one is essentially using an unlicensed drug. Forskolin appears to be safe, but more studies need to be undertaken before it can be recommended for self-treatment.
Ma huang. The Chinese herb ma huang, also called ephedra, is
definitely effective for mild asthma because it contains the drug ephedrine.
However, it is not recommended because of safety concerns. This Chinese herb is a
member of a primitive family of plants that look like thin, branching, connected
straws. A related species, Ephedra nevadensis, grows wild in the
American Southwest and is widely called Mormon tea. However, only the Asian
species of ephedra contains the active compounds ephedrine and
pseudoephedrine.
Ma huang was traditionally used by Chinese herbalists in the early stages of
respiratory infections and for the short-term treatment of certain kinds of
asthma, eczema, hay fever, narcolepsy,
and edema. Japanese chemists isolated ephedrine from ma huang
around the beginning of the twentieth century, and it soon became a primary
treatment for asthma in the United States and abroad. Ephedra’s other major
ingredient, pseudoephedrine, became the decongestant Sudafed.
Although ephedrine can still be found in a few over-the-counter asthma drugs, physicians seldom prescribe it today. The problem is that ephedrine mimics the effects of adrenaline and causes symptoms such as rapid heartbeat, high blood pressure, agitation, insomnia, nausea, and loss of appetite. The newer asthma drugs are much safer and easier to tolerate. This is a situation in which synthetic drugs are less dangerous than a natural one. Ma huang is not recommended for use in treating asthma.
Other Proposed Natural Treatments
Other herbs and supplements. In a double-blind trial, thirty-two people with steroid-dependent asthma were given either placebo or essential oil of eucalyptus for twelve weeks. The results showed that people using eucalyptus were more able to gradually reduce their steroid dosage than those taking placebo.
Two double-blind, placebo-controlled studies enrolling more than eighty people with asthma suggest that oligomeric proanthocyanidins from pine bark might reduce symptoms. An extract made from ivy leaf has been advocated for the treatment of childhood asthma, but the meaningful supporting evidence is again limited to one placebo-controlled trial.
Another small, double-blind, placebo-controlled study evaluated the effects of four weeks of treatment with a Japanese herbal mixture traditionally called Saiboku-To. Researchers tested the tendency of the bronchial tubes to contract in response to an asthma-producing substance called methacholine. The results indicated that the use of Saiboku-To helped prevent such contractions, and it also reduced lung inflammation. Another study reportedly found benefit with a combination named Mai-Men-Dong-Tang.
Many studies have been conducted on the effects of vitamin C in
treating asthma, but the evidence that it works remains inconsistent and highly
incomplete. There is only weak and inconsistent evidence regarding whether two
antioxidants in the carotenoid family, lycopene and beta-carotene, might help
prevent exercise-induced asthma. One double-blind comparative study provides weak
evidence that the Ayurvedic herbal combination called Astha might be helpful for
mild asthma.
Vitamin B6 is often mentioned as a treatment for asthma, but the evidence that it works is weak and contradictory at best. A double-blind study of seventy-six children with asthma found significant benefit from vitamin B6 after the second month of usage. Children in the treated group were able to reduce their doses of bronchodilators and steroids. However, a recent double-blind study of thirty-one adults who also used either inhaled or oral steroids did not show any benefit. Supplementation with vitamin B12 is also often said to be effective for asthma. However, the scientific evidence in its favor consists almost entirely of open studies that did not attempt to eliminate the placebo effect.
Preliminary evidence hints that the herb butterbur may be helpful for asthma. Another study found potential benefit with the spice Carum copticum.
Essential fatty acids, such as gamma-linolenic acid and those found in fish
oil, as well as flaxseed oil, may inhibit inflammatory responses such as those
that occur in asthma. However, of the studies that tried fish oil as a
treatment for asthma, most failed to find significant clinical benefit; one study
found that fish oil can worsen aspirin-related asthma. Nonetheless, there is some
evidence from one research group that fish oil might be helpful for
exercise-induced asthma. There is also some preliminary evidence that women who
take fish oil during late pregnancy may reduce the risk of asthma in their
children for up to sixteen years after birth.
A study of seventy-two children with moderate, persistent asthma found that combined or single supplementation with omega-3 oils, zinc, or vitamin C improved their symptoms and lung function. Combined supplementation was associated with the greatest improvement. The reliability of these results should be questioned, however, because about 20 percent of the children dropped out before the end of the thirty-eight-week study.
A preliminary double-blind, placebo-controlled trial suggests that green-lipped mussel extract might be helpful for allergic asthma. Another study suggests that the natural substance hyaluronic acid might be helpful for asthma when taken by inhalation.
Natural medicine practitioners frequently recommend the flavonoid quercetin as a treatment for asthma. However, the only basis for this recommendation consists of a few older, preliminary test-tube studies that suggest it might inhibit the release of inflammatory substances from special cells called mast cells. The asthma drugs Intal (cromolyn) and Tilade (nedocromil) are believed to work in this way. However, there is significant direct evidence from human trials that Tilade and Intal taken by inhalation actually work. In contrast, no such evidence exists for quercetin taken in any manner; and it is highly unlikely that oral intake of quercetin could produce levels in the body similar to the levels used in those test-tube studies.
Alternative medical literature frequently mentions magnesium as a treatment for asthma. However, this idea seems to be based primarily on the use of intravenous magnesium as an emergency treatment for asthma. (Taking something by mouth is very different from having it injected into the veins.) Studies of oral magnesium for asthma have shown more negative than positive results, but some evidence exists that intravenous or inhaled magnesium may be beneficial. Also, preliminary evidence, far too weak to be relied upon, has been used to suggest that the supplement coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) might be helpful for asthma.
Other natural products commonly recommended for asthma include the herbs aloe, brahmi (Bacopa monniera), chamomile, damiana, elecampane, garlic, grindelia, horehound, hyssop, licorice, marshmallow, mullein, onion, reishi, and yerba santa, and the supplements adrenal extract and betaine hydrochloride. Lobelia inflata is sometimes recommended as an herbal treatment for asthma; according to traditional directions, though, it should be taken to the point of vomiting. None of these treatments has any meaningful supporting evidence.
Antioxidants, such as vitamin E, beta-carotene, and selenium, are frequently recommended for asthma on the grounds that they may protect inflamed lung tissue. Although one study found that asthmatics placed on a low antioxidant diet for ten days experienced a worsening of their symptoms, there is no direct scientific evidence that antioxidant supplementation improves asthma. A rather theoretical study found evidence that the use of vitamin E might decrease the inflammatory response in children with asthma exposed to ozone. However, a far more meaningful double-blind, placebo-controlled study found vitamin E (as 500 mg of natural vitamin E) ineffective for asthma. Similarly, a large (almost two-hundred-participant) study failed to find selenium helpful for asthma.
The herb picrorhiza has been advocated as a treatment for asthma, based primarily on two studies conducted in the 1970s. However, none of these studies reached modern scientific standards. Two subsequent, and better-designed, studies of picrorhiza failed to find the herb more effective than placebo.
One study failed to find a mixture of probiotics
(friendly bacteria) helpful for asthma in children. Another study, though, found
that a mixture of probiotic Bifidobacterium breve and the
prebiotic galacto- and fructo-oligosaccharide may help reduce wheezing in infants
with eczema.
Children with asthma may have reduced growth, possibly from the use of inhaled
steroids. One study failed to find protective benefits with a multivitamin that
contained vitamin
D. The tested supplement did not contain calcium. Other
studies have found that combination treatment with both calcium and vitamin D may
protect bone density in people taking oral corticosteroids (for various reasons, including asthma).
Two preliminary studies reported by one research group have led to publicized
concerns that the use of the insomnia supplement melatonin may
worsen night-time asthma. However, one double-blind study of melatonin in people
with asthma found evidence of improved sleep without the worsening of asthma
symptoms.
Acupuncture. Although there have been numerous reports on
acupuncture treatment for asthma, the results have been
contradictory. A team of three researchers analyzed thirteen trials on acupuncture
in the treatment of asthma. These studies were scored on the basis of design
quality, with a maximum possible score of 100 points. Criteria for assigning
points included size of the study population, randomization procedure, description
of treatment, measurement of effects, and follow-up. Eight studies earned more
than 50 points, and the highest score was 72 points. However, the overall quality
of studies was judged to be mediocre; in any case, the results were contradictory.
The conclusion was that “claims that acupuncture is effective in the treatment of
asthma are not based on the results of well-performed clinical trials.” A more
recent review of acupuncture for asthma came to identical conclusions.
Other alternative therapies. Sublingual
immunotherapy, a form of “allergy shot” that involves drops
under the tongue rather than injections, has shown promise for asthma. Some people
with asthma may also have food allergies. One way to discover a food allergy is to
eliminate potentially allergenic foods from the diet, then to systematically
reintroduce them to the diet to see if a reaction occurs. This elimination diet
should be done only under the care of a doctor because of the risk of severe
allergic reaction. Other ways to diagnose a food allergy include the skin scratch
test and blood tests (such as RAST or ELISA). Persons with a food allergy who
eliminate the offending food from the diet might reduce their asthma symptoms.
A special breathing technique called Buteyko breathing may reduce medication use and subjective symptoms, though it does not appear to actually improve lung function. Hypnosis, massage, yoga, and some other forms of relaxation therapy may offer modest benefits for asthma. The same is true of standard aerobic exercise.
In two controlled studies, chiropractic spinal manipulation has failed to prove
more effective than fake manipulation for treatment of asthma. One study of
osteopathic
manipulation reportedly found benefits, but the study’s
design was flawed.
Homeopathic Remedies
In a double-blind, placebo-controlled study of forty people with asthma severe enough to require corticosteroid treatment, the use of an injected homeopathic remedy consisting of Asclepias vincetoxicum and sulphur significantly improved symptoms.
Bibliography
Biltagi, M. A., et al. “Omega-3 Fatty Acids, Vitamin C and Zn Supplementation in Asthmatic Children.” Acta Paediatrica 98 (2009): 737-742.
Campos, F. L., et al. “Melatonin Improves Sleep in Asthma.” American Journal of Respiratory Critical Care Medicine 170 (2004): 947-951.
Cowie, R. L., et al. “A Randomised Controlled Trial of the Buteyko Technique as an Adjunct to Conventional Management of Asthma.” Respiratory Medicine 102 (2008): 726-732.
Falk, B., et al. “Effect of Lycopene Supplementation on Lung Function After Exercise in Young Athletes Who Complain of Exercise-Induced Bronchoconstriction Symptoms.” Annals of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology 94 (2005): 480-485.
Giovannini, M., et al. “A Randomized Prospective Double Blind Controlled Trial on Effects of Long-Term Consumption of Fermented Milk Containing Lactobacillus casei in Pre-school Children with Allergic Asthma and/or Rhinitis.” Pediatric Research 62 (2007): 215-220.
Gontijo-Amaral, C., et al. “Oral Magnesium Supplementation in Asthmatic Children.” European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 61 (2006): 54-60.
Guiney, P. A., et al. “Effects of Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment on Pediatric Patients with Asthma.” Journal of the American Osteopathic Association 105 (2005): 7-12.
Gvozdjakova, A., et al. “Coenzyme Q10 Supplementation Reduces Corticosteroids Dosage in Patients with Bronchial Asthma.” Biofactors 25 (2006): 235-240.
Hsu, C. H., et al. “Efficacy and Safety of Modified Mai-Men-Dong-Tang for Treatment of Allergic Asthma.” Pediatric Allergy and Immunology 16 (2005): 76-81.
Huntley, A., A. R. White, and E. Ernst. “Relaxation Therapies for Asthma.” Thorax 57 (2002): 127-131.
Matusiewicz, R. “The Homeopathic Treatment of Corticosteroid-Dependent Asthma.” Biomedical Therapy 15 (1997): 117-122.
Mickleborough, T. D., et al. “Protective Effect of Fish Oil Supplementation on Exercise-Induced Bronchoconstriction in Asthma.” Chest 129 (2006): 39-49.
Mihrshahi, S., et al. “Eighteen-Month Outcomes of House Dust Mite Avoidance and Dietary Fatty Acid Modification in the Childhood Asthma Prevention Study (CAPS).” Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 111 (2003): 162-168.
Olsen, S. F., et al. “Fish Oil Intake Compared with Olive Oil Intake in Late Pregnancy and Asthma in the Offspring.” American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 88 (2008): 167-175.
Ram, F. S., S. M. Robinson, and P. N. Black. “Effects of Physical Training in Asthma.” British Journal of Sports Medicine 34 (2000): 162-167.
Sabina, A. B., et al. “Yoga Intervention for Adults with Mild-to-Moderate Asthma.” Annals of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology 94 (2005): 543-548.
Schubert, R., et al. “Effect of N-3 Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids in Asthma After Low-Dose Allergen Challenge.” International Archives of Allergy and Immunology 148 (2009): 321-329.
Sienra-Monge, J. J., et al. “Antioxidant Supplementation and Nasal Inflammatory Responses Among Young Asthmatics Exposed to High Levels of Ozone.” Clinical and Experimental Immunology 138 (2004): 317-322.
Sutherland, E. R., et al. “Elevated Serum Melatonin Is Associated with the Nocturnal Worsening of Asthma.” Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 112 (2003): 513-517.
Van der Aa, L. B., et al. “Synbiotics Prevent Asthma-Like Symptoms in Infants with Atopic Dermatitis.” Allergy (June 17, 2010).
Vempati, R., R. L. Bijlani, and K. K. Deepak. “The Efficacy of a Comprehensive Lifestyle Modification Programme Based on Yoga in the Management of Bronchial Asthma.” BMC Pulmonary Medicine 9 (2009): 37.
No comments:
Post a Comment